Different cookie baking sheets provide different cooking results! It’s a simple fact that’s often overlooked when baking cookies. With so many different choices, how do you know which cookie baking sheets will work best for you? Let’s look at the different choices available a little closer:

Insulated Non-stick Cookie Baking Sheets:

Most insulated cookie sheets are made to be non-stick. If you choose insulated cooking sheets, they do tend to be a little more expensive, but it’s money well spent. There’s a pocket of air between the top and the bottom, and it helps create a nice even heat. These cookie baking sheets usually last awhile, and are a good quality. These are a reliable choice. They help the cookies to bake evening, and help prevent burning on the bottoms of your cookies. The insulated cookie baking sheet helps prevent hot spots which regular cookie sheets sometimes get.

Aluminum Cookie Sheets:

These are a common cookie sheet that many people use. The aluminum helps produce an evenly baked product, due to it’s ability to conduct heat well. Aluminum sheets are sturdy, though you’ll want to get the heavier version. Light or thinner versions of an aluminum cooking baking sheet can bend and warp. This can cause your cookies to bake unevenly.

Non-Stick Cookie Baking Sheets:

I love non-stick pans and cookie sheets, don’t you? It’s made things a whole lot easier. No more scraping items off a pan, no more greasing your pan, and clean up is a snap. Their non-stick coating makes a product that works well and is easy to brown. Now, one thing to keep in mind is that the darker the surface, the faster your cookies will brown. You’ll want to watch your cookies as you get close to the end of the cookie time, so you can adjust accordingly.

What do I recommend? At my house, while we’ve used different kinds over the years, the true and tried best cookies we’ve made were made on the AirBake Cookie Baking Sheets. We get CONSISTENT results, don’t burn the bottoms, and have lasted in great shape.

While cookie sheets come in different styles, what you need to do is watch those cookies in those last few moments until you’re familiar with how your oven is cooking on your cookie sheets. Darker pans may yield different results than lighter pans. A warped cookie sheet may yield inconsistent results. Burnt bottoms can be an issue if you don’t watch them. You can’t go wrong with AirBake cookie baking sheets. These are the only ones I like to use now. Spend a little more now, and you’ll get great cookie sheets that will last you for years.